BlueReader

After Pride and Prejudice

Which Jane Austen Novel to Read Next

Most readers meet Austen through Pride and Prejudice, enjoy it, and then stall. The other five novels sit on the shelf looking interchangeable, and the usual advice, that they are all good, does not help you pick one for Tuesday night.

They are not interchangeable. Each one takes something you may have liked in Pride and Prejudice and makes it the center of a different book, while dropping something else. This guide sorts the five by what carried you through the first one, describes how each opens and how it is built, and leaves the marriages alone. If you have not read Pride and Prejudice yet, our first-time reading guide is the place to begin, and Which Jane Austen Novel Should You Read First? compares all six without assuming any of them.

Start from what you liked

What held you in Pride and PrejudiceRead nextWhat changes
Elizabeth’s quick judgments and the cost of being wrongEmmaThe heroine is wrong more often and the narrator stays closer to her
The long wait between a misunderstanding and its repairPersuasionThe misunderstanding is years old before the book begins
Jane and Elizabeth as sisters who confide in each otherSense and SensibilityTwo sisters with opposite temperaments carry the whole novel
The narrator’s jokes at the expense of Mr. Collins and Mrs. BennetNorthanger AbbeyThe jokes are aimed at novels themselves, including this one
Charlotte Lucas, money, and what a woman without it can afford to refuseMansfield ParkA poor relation in a rich house, with far less room to speak

The table is a starting point, not a verdict. Each section below says more about what you are signing up for.

Emma: if you liked watching Elizabeth misjudge people

Emma opens with its heroine at nearly twenty-one, “handsome, clever, and rich,” living with an anxious father in the village of Highbury and recently deprived of her governess by that lady’s marriage. Emma decides that she arranged the match, and looks for someone else to arrange.1

This is the novel for readers who enjoyed Elizabeth Bennet’s confidence most when it was about to be punctured. The difference is scale. Elizabeth misreads two men; Emma misreads nearly everyone, and the narration keeps you inside her head while quietly supplying the evidence she ignores. The book is built in three volumes of eighteen, eighteen, and nineteen chapters, and the volume breaks fall at natural pauses.

It is the longest of the five and the slowest to start. Give it until Harriet Smith arrives before deciding. The reward is the funniest cast Austen wrote, including a talker, Miss Bates, whose monologues are worth reading aloud.

Persuasion: if you liked the long wait

Persuasion opens not with a daughter but with a father. Sir Walter Elliot of Kellynch Hall reads no book but the Baronetage, where he can study his own entry, and his vanity and debts set the household in motion. His second daughter, Anne, is twenty-seven, overlooked by her family, and carrying an engagement broken off eight years before on the advice of a friend.2

If what you remember from Pride and Prejudice is the stretch between Darcy’s letter and the visit to Pemberley, when nothing is settled and every meeting carries weight, this is your book. It is short, twenty-four chapters, and much of it is about what is not said in a room. Anne hears conversations she cannot join and watches a man she once knew be polite to her.

It is also the quietest of the five, with less open comedy. Readers who wanted more of Mr. Bennet’s dry remarks may find Sir Walter’s foolishness less fun to watch, because the narrator does not share the joke with him.

Sense and Sensibility: if you liked the sisters

Sense and Sensibility begins with an inheritance. The Dashwood estate of Norland in Sussex passes to a son by a first marriage, and the widow and her three daughters must leave the house and live on much less. Elinor, the eldest, manages feeling; Marianne, the second, displays it.3

Jane and Elizabeth Bennet are close but alike in their good sense. Elinor and Marianne are close and disagree about almost everything, and the novel is the record of each sister learning what the other’s way of loving costs. The fifty chapters are short, and the book moves between Devonshire and London with a change of scene that helps if you read in sessions.

Do not trust the title to tell you which sister is right. Austen gives both of them real grievances, and the people around them, especially the gossiping Mrs. Jennings and the chilly John Dashwood, are drawn with the same sharp pen that produced Lady Catherine.

Northanger Abbey: if you liked the narrator

Northanger Abbey was finished in 1803 and published only after Austen’s death. The Gutenberg text includes her short Advertisement explaining the delay and warning that thirteen years had made parts of the book out of date.4 Catherine Morland, a clergyman’s daughter who has read a great many Gothic novels, is taken to Bath by family friends and begins to meet people.

This is the book for readers who laughed at the narrator’s sentences more than at the characters. Austen breaks in constantly, tells you that Catherine is not the heroine a novel ought to have, and sends up the fiction Catherine loves. The thirty-one chapters are the shortest run of the five, and the first half, in Bath, is almost entirely social comedy.

Some knowledge of the Gothic novels Catherine reads adds a layer, but it is not required. The jokes about them explain themselves, and the people Catherine meets, including a brother and sister named Thorpe, need no annotation at all.

Mansfield Park: if you liked Charlotte Lucas

Mansfield Park opens about thirty years before its story, with Miss Maria Ward of Huntingdon marrying Sir Thomas Bertram and rising to the rank of a baronet’s lady on seven thousand pounds. Her sisters marry less well, and one of them has too many children. Fanny Price, aged ten, is sent from a crowded house in Portsmouth to be raised at Mansfield Park among cousins who are kind to her in the way one is kind to a dependant.5

If the scene in Pride and Prejudice that stayed with you was Charlotte’s defense of her marriage, this is the Austen novel that takes money and dependence seriously from the first page to the last. Fanny is quiet, often ill, and almost never in a position to say what she thinks. The forty-eight chapters give a great deal of room to the people who have that position and use it badly.

It is the hardest of the five to love on first reading, and the one most readers return to. Go in expecting a book about a household rather than a courtship, and watch what is said about Sir Thomas’s property in Antigua.

Reading the five in order of effort

If you want the surest pleasure, read Emma or Northanger Abbey. If you want the book closest to the feeling of Pride and Prejudice’s second half, read Persuasion. Save Mansfield Park for when you are ready to be uncomfortable, and read Sense and Sensibility whenever two sisters sound better company than one heroine. The novels contain no violence and little that needs a content note beyond the period’s assumptions about class, servants, and the slave plantation that supports the Bertram household.

All five are free on Project Gutenberg in their original English. Download the EPUB, upload it to BlueReader, and open it from your bookshelf after server processing; every title here divides into chapters short enough to finish in one sitting, and the same account keeps your place across devices.6 If after all five you still want more, the short novel in letters Lady Susan appears in our guide to classic epistolary novels.


Footnotes

  1. Project Gutenberg, Emma, eBook No. 158. Three volumes of eighteen, eighteen, and nineteen chapters; first published 1815. ↩

  2. Project Gutenberg, Persuasion, eBook No. 105. Twenty-four chapters; published posthumously in 1817. ↩

  3. Project Gutenberg, Sense and Sensibility, eBook No. 161. Fifty chapters; first published 1811. ↩

  4. Project Gutenberg, Northanger Abbey, eBook No. 121. Thirty-one chapters and the author’s Advertisement noting completion in 1803; published posthumously in 1817. ↩

  5. Project Gutenberg, Mansfield Park, eBook No. 141. Forty-eight chapters; first published 1814. ↩

  6. BlueReader browser reading guide and free EPUB guide: EPUB upload and server processing before reading. ↩

More author guides

Read your EPUB in BlueReader

Add the EPUB to your bookshelf, wait for server processing, then open it in your browser.

Sign in to add an EPUB