BlueReader

Classic American Short Stories

Where to Start, from Irving to Sherwood Anderson

The American short story is where many of the country’s writers did their sharpest work, but the free texts come packaged in thick collections. A reader who wants “Rip Van Winkle” is handed a 130,000-word sketch book; a reader curious about Bierce gets a volume of collected works.

This guide picks seven collections on Project Gutenberg, running from 1819 to 1919, and names one or two stories in each to open first. Every pick is a complete text, not an excerpt. The descriptions stop at the setup, and nothing here gives away how a story turns.

Edgar Allan Poe is absent only because he has his own guide, Poe beyond “The Raven”. Read that alongside this one.

Pick the century, place, or mood that interests you

CollectionOpen firstSetting
The Sketch-Book of Geoffrey Crayon (1819-20)“Rip Van Winkle”Hudson valley, Dutch villages
Twice-Told Tales (1837/1842)“The Minister’s Black Veil”Puritan New England
The Luck of Roaring Camp and Other Tales (1870)“The Outcasts of Poker Flat”California mining camps
In the Midst of Life (1891)“An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge”The Civil War
The Yellow Wallpaper (1892)The single storyA rented summer house
The Country of the Pointed Firs (1896)“The Return” and “Mrs. Todd”A Maine fishing village
Winesburg, Ohio (1919)“Hands”A small Midwestern town

1. Washington Irving, “Rip Van Winkle”

The Sketch-Book of Geoffrey Crayon, Gent. is a miscellany: essays on English country life, a long Christmas sequence, and a handful of tales. Two of those tales are the reason to download it. “Rip Van Winkle” is presented as a paper found among the effects of the late Diedrich Knickerbocker, “an old gentleman of New York,” who collected the legends of the Dutch settlers. The story proper then opens in a village at the foot of the Kaatskill mountains.1

Read it for the frame as much as the tale. Irving pretends to be an editor passing on someone else’s manuscript, and the mock-scholarly tone is where the comedy lives. “The Legend of Sleepy Hollow,” near the end of the book, uses the same device.

2. Nathaniel Hawthorne, “The Minister’s Black Veil”

Twice-Told Tales collects Hawthorne’s early magazine stories; the Gutenberg text follows an 1889 printing. “The Minister’s Black Veil,” subtitled “A Parable,” begins with a sexton pulling at the bell-rope of the Milford meeting-house on a Sunday morning and the congregation gathering, until the Reverend Mr. Hooper appears at his door.2

Hawthorne tells you what the strange thing is in the first page and then spends the story on how people respond to it. That is his method in general. “Dr. Heidegger’s Experiment,” which opens with an old doctor inviting four elderly friends to his study, and “Wakefield,” which starts from a newspaper anecdote about a man who left his wife, work the same way. Read any one of the three, then decide whether you want the rest.

3. Bret Harte, “The Outcasts of Poker Flat”

The Luck of Roaring Camp and Other Tales gathers the California stories that made Harte famous, with his own general introduction. The title story opens with a commotion in a mining camp in 1850 and a woman’s name repeated in low voices. “The Outcasts of Poker Flat” opens with the gambler John Oakhurst stepping into the main street on the morning of November 23, 1850, and sensing “a change in its moral atmosphere.”3

Harte’s narrator is dry and a little amused, and his subject is how rough men behave when something unexpected asks them to be better than their habits. Start with “Outcasts,” then “Tennessee’s Partner.” The literary parodies later in the volume (“Muck-a-Muck,” “Miss Mix”) can wait.

4. Ambrose Bierce, “An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge”

In the Midst of Life: Tales of Soldiers and Civilians is volume two of Bierce’s collected works, and it is divided into exactly those two groups. The Gutenberg text includes his short 1891 preface, in which he records that the book had been “denied existence by the chief publishing houses of the country.”4

“An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge” begins with a man standing on a railroad bridge in northern Alabama, his wrists bound, a rope around his neck, and soldiers around him. Everything the story does, it does from that position. Read it in one sitting without interruption; it is short and depends on your not stopping. “A Horseman in the Sky,” the first story in the book, opens with a sentry asleep at his post in western Virginia in 1861 and is a good second choice. The civilian stories lean toward horror and are closer to Poe.

5. Charlotte Perkins Gilman, “The Yellow Wallpaper”

This is the only pick that is a single story rather than a collection, and at about 6,000 words it can be read in half an hour. It is written as a private journal. The narrator and her husband John, a physician, have taken a colonial mansion for the summer, and she is under his instruction to rest. She confides on the first page that she is writing on “dead paper” because she cannot say these things to a living soul.5

Everything depends on voice. Notice how the entries change in length and in what they attend to, and how often the narrator reports John’s opinion of her condition. Do not read a summary first; the story is short enough that any summary replaces it.

6. Sarah Orne Jewett, The Country of the Pointed Firs

The Country of the Pointed Firs is twenty-one linked sketches rather than separate stories, held together by one narrator: a woman writer who returns to the Maine coastal village of Dunnet Landing for a summer and lodges with Mrs. Todd, the local herbalist. The first chapter, “The Return,” is barely two pages. The second, “Mrs. Todd,” introduces the landlady and her garden.6

Nothing much happens, and that is the point. Jewett is interested in talk, in old sailors with stories, and in how a community remembers itself. At about 45,000 words it is the longest continuous read here, but the chapters are short and each closes cleanly.

7. Sherwood Anderson, “Hands”

Winesburg, Ohio is subtitled “A Group of Tales of Ohio Small Town Life,” and the Gutenberg text includes Anderson’s own table, “The Tales and the Persons,” which lists each story with the character it concerns. The book opens with “The Book of the Grotesque,” a short prologue about an old writer having his bed raised so he can see the trees from his window.7

“Hands,” the first tale proper, begins on the half-decayed veranda of a small frame house near a ravine outside Winesburg, where a fat little old man walks nervously up and down. He is Wing Biddlebaum, and the story is about why he cannot keep his hands still. Anderson’s prose is plain and repetitive in a deliberate way, and many of the stories involve George Willard, a young newspaper reporter who appears in other people’s lives. You can read the tales singly, but they gain from order.

Content note

Harte’s stories use period racial language about Chinese, Native American, and Mexican characters, and the narrator’s humor sometimes depends on it; Irving’s Sketch-Book includes two essays on Native Americans written from an 1819 viewpoint. Bierce’s war stories describe wounds and death without softening. “The Yellow Wallpaper” depicts mental illness and a medical regime that worsens it. Anderson’s tales include grief, loneliness, and a sexual accusation handled indirectly; Hawthorne’s turn on guilt and death.

Keep the collections together

Each collection links to its Project Gutenberg page in the footnotes, where you can download an EPUB. Upload the file to BlueReader, wait for the server to finish processing it, then open it from your bookshelf and use the table of contents to jump to the story you want.8

For more American short fiction in the same spirit, Mark Twain’s “Jumping Frog” is a twenty-minute companion to Harte, Melville’s “Bartleby” sits naturally beside Hawthorne, and Kate Chopin’s stories belong next to Jewett and Gilman.


Footnotes

  1. Project Gutenberg, The Sketch-Book of Geoffrey Crayon, Gent., eBook No. 2048. First published 1819-20. Contains “Rip Van Winkle” and “The Legend of Sleepy Hollow.” ↩

  2. Project Gutenberg, Twice-Told Tales, eBook No. 13707. Collection first published 1837, expanded 1842; the text follows an 1889 printing. ↩

  3. Project Gutenberg, The Luck of Roaring Camp and Other Tales, eBook No. 6373. Collection first published 1870; this is the Riverside Edition with the author’s general introduction. ↩

  4. Project Gutenberg, The Collected Works of Ambrose Bierce, Volume 2: In the Midst of Life, eBook No. 13334. First published 1891 as Tales of Soldiers and Civilians; collected edition 1909. ↩

  5. Project Gutenberg, The Yellow Wallpaper, eBook No. 1952. First published 1892. A single story of about 6,000 words. ↩

  6. Project Gutenberg, The Country of the Pointed Firs, eBook No. 367. First published 1896. Twenty-one chapters. ↩

  7. Project Gutenberg, Winesburg, Ohio, eBook No. 416. First published 1919. Prologue, “The Tales and the Persons,” and the tales, several concerning George Willard. ↩

  8. BlueReader browser reading guide and free EPUB guide: EPUB upload and server processing before reading. ↩

More reading lists

Read your EPUB in BlueReader

Add the EPUB to your bookshelf, wait for server processing, then open it in your browser.

Sign in to add an EPUB